Testicular seminoma affects young men and is associated with very favorable prognosis. The evolution in treatment paradigm has focused on minimizing acute and especially late toxicities. Following orchiectomy, while surveillance is favored in Stage I patients, radiotherapy (RT) is a standard treatment option for de novo or relapsed stage IIA or select non-bulky stage IIB disease. Despite low doses, standard RT fields to paraaortic and pelvic lymphatics using x-rays exposes a large volume of uninvolved normal tissue/viscera to excess dose. This young patient population is especially vulnerable to risks of late RT toxicities including secondary malignancy. Proton beam therapy (PBT) has dosimetric advantage over x-ray-based RT due to lack of exit dose, and comparative dosimetric/modeling studies show significant sparing of uninvolved abdominal/pelvic organs. However, there is scant reported clinical data at this time for PBT. We review our early institutional outcomes with PBT for testicular seminoma.
Single institution retrospective review from a tertiary care center of patients treated with PBT from 2013-2022 for testicular seminoma. Recurrence free (RFS) and overall survival (OS) were calculated from the completion of PBT. Toxicities were graded (Gr) using CTCAE v5.0.
Four patients underwent PBT, median age 39 (range 36-47). All were Stage I at diagnosis (pT1b n = 3; pT2 n = 1) and were treated for recurrent stage II disease (IIA n = 3; IIB n = 1) at a median of 34 months from orchiectomy (range 3 - 74 months). Nodal extent included 2 with multiple paraaortic nodes, 1 with solitary paraaortic node and 1 with solitary pelvic node. PBT was delivered with pencil-beam scanning, treating paraaortic + ipsilateral pelvic fields (20 Gy in 10 fractions), then sequential boost to involved nodes (10 -16 Gy in 5-8 fractions). Typically, PA or posterior oblique fields were used to minimize dose to out-of-field abdominal/pelvic viscera. Treatment was well tolerated with minimal acute toxicities: fatigue Gr 1 (n = 3), nausea Gr 1 (n = 3). No Gr 2 or higher acute toxicities or significant late toxicities were observed. At median follow up of 30 months (range 3 - 54), no recurrences were observed, and RFS and OS were 100%. Two patients are without evidence of disease > 4 years post-treatment.
In this case series, PBT for retroperitoneal and pelvic metastases in Stage IIA/IIB testicular seminoma was associated with oncologic efficacy with minimal toxicity. PBT reduces unnecessary dose to abdominal/pelvic organs compared to x-ray techniques, which is advantageous in young patients who have anticipated long-term survival. This is one of the few series reporting clinical outcomes of PBT in the management of seminoma. Randomized comparisons with x-ray approaches are impractical given the relatively low volume of patients receiving RT in modern seminoma management, so it is essential to report and track longitudinal outcomes across institutions to validate this approach.
International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics. 2023 Oct 01 [Epub]
A Lui, J Zeng, J Chen, E S Weg, W Ellis, S P Psutka, Y A Nyame, T Yezefski, D Lin, G Schade, J J Liao
University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, WA., Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Washington - Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center, Seattle, WA., University of Washington, Seattle, WA.